-
Key Lime Pie Is here! 🍋🟩
Perfectly tart, creamy, and limitied-edition for the summer. Get a taste before it’s gone. -
DITCH THE BLOCK 🚫 Grab a spoon 🥄
Small-batch spoonable fudge. No slicing. No mess. Build your box in 60 seconds.
1000+ Happy Customers
Made in TN
Ships Fast
Gift Ready
No refrigeration
Happiness guaranteed
As Seen In
Our Flavors
Scroll & tap a flavor to explore.
Key Lime Pie
Tart, creamy key lime, pure summer.
- Zesty lime kick
- Smooth, creamy finish
- All the pie, none of the crumbs
I feel like I am in Key West in the summertime. Tastes exactly like a perfect Key Lime pie bite, every time.
Tom D. ✓ Verified Customer
It's creamy, and tart, and those graham cracker crust pieces make it perfect. Talk about ADDICTING!
Jenny A. ✓ Verified Customer
Classic Peanut Butter
Tastes like the middle of a peanut butter cup.
- Soft PB center, now the whole jar
- Melt-in-your-mouth, always spoonable
- The one you keep going back to
Hands down the best peanut butter fudge on the market!
Courtney S. ✓ Verified Customer
ADDICTING! Tastes like the inside of a Reese’s. Hands down this is #1 for sure 🤩
Dani B. ✓ Verified Customer
Cookies 'n Dream
Cookies and cream, but make it spoonable.
- Real cookie pieces in every scoop
- Creamy vanilla fudge base
- No baking, just dig in
When we sampled this, we couldn’t believe how much this tasted like the middle of an Oreo. Spot on, delicious! Definitely my favorite flavor.
Michelle D. ✓ Verified Customer
Okkkk wow. You know when you’re eating an Oreo and you want to eat all the cream from the inside of the cookies?! This fudge tastes exactly like doing that. With actual cookies crushed up in there too for the full experience. This one is decadent!!
Skye S. ✓ Verified Customer
Back soonBerry Ever After
Blueberry cheesecake in a jar.
- Sweet blueberry swirl
- Tangy cheesecake fudge
- Graham-cracker comfort
I don't know how you guys do it - but this tastes like a bite of cheesecake. I will be back for more very soon I can tell.
Joe F. ✓ Verified Customer
WOW that's all I have to say. This is fantastic fudge. Bursting with blueberry flavor, then you get the cheesecake on the end of it. Just WOW.
Jen D. ✓ Verified Customer
Build Your Box
Pick 2, 3, or 4 jars and mix any flavors — the more you stack, the more you save!
Connecting…
1 · Pick your size
2 · Pick your flavors
Your flight
Small Batch
Spoonable
Ready to Ship
Giftable
Size check
A full 12 oz jar = 3× a standard tub
Most spoonable treats come in tiny 2–4 oz cups. Ours is a full 12 oz — way more to dig into.
12 oz
Fudge Fairy
VS
2–4 oz
the usual treat
3×
bigger than a 4 oz tub
~12
spoonfuls per jar
≈ $1
per serving in a 4-pack
Happiness 100% Guaranteed.
Real Reviews from Our Customers
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 1000+ Customers Who Love Us
Don't Believe Us?
Here's what people are saying after their first spoonful...
★★★★★
This peanut butter fudge is addictive! One of the only sweet treats I truly enjoy.
Palmer A.
Verified
★★★★★
I bought three jars of this oreo flavor. It’s already all gone! Purchasing more now!
Evan D.
Verified
★★★★★
This fudge is DELICIOUS and SO addicting. The Peanut Butter is absolutely delicious 🤤 the best fudge we’ve ever had!
Emma K.
Verified
★★★★★
I mean, this has to be the most addicting, decadent, smooth cookies and cream fudge I have ever had.
Angela S.
Verified
Here's why people keep coming back for more…
Real ingredients. No knife needed. Built to be eaten straight out of the jar.
Jacqueline, Founder & Owner
👑 WinnerFudge Fairy
The Other Guys
Spoonably Soft 🥄
No Knives Needed
Mess Free
Modern Mash-Ups
Small Batch Crafted 💜
SPOONABLE FUDGE • NO KNIVES REQUIRED • SHIPS NATIONWIDE
There's No Wrong Way to Fudge
1
Spoon It
Straight from the jar like a pint of ice cream, honestly our fav!
2
Spread It
On toast, waffles, biscuits - dream up your new fudge combo.
3
Melt It
Warm it, then drizzle over ice cream or dip your fav fruit.
*every flavor but Classic PB
← swipe to see more →
#SpoonableFudge
Join the Movement
1,000+ spoons and counting. Tag us and you could end up on this wall.
Build Your Box
@fudgefairyco
@Jackiecas1
